Case Study: The Atrium

The Atrium

Air Source Heat Pump Case Study

Project Summary


The Atrium Building, a 7-story office building owned by Jawl Properties and located in Victoria, British Columbia, was built in 2010 with a Modular Air Source Heat Pump (ASHP) – one of the first implemented at this scale in British Columbia. As the system neared the end of its life, Jawl’s operation team identified an opportunity to learn from their experience with the original unit to inform the project to replace it. The original system had functioned reasonably well during the heating season but struggled to provide adequate cooling capacity during the summer. Jawl wanted to ensure the new system would be reliable, trouble free, and improve tenant comfort year-round.

Jawl initiated the project by talking to their primary HVAC provider, who was familiar with the system and the building, to identify specific aspects of system performance that needed to be improved. Next, they brought in a consultant to lead a collaborative process to design the new system. An initial feasibility study identified some issues with the flow rates between the ASHP and the primary mechanical plant, and some capacity challenges stemming from load requirements and space usages that changed from the original design of the building. The study identified several options, including heat recovery and a dedicated high efficiency chiller for summer cooling, for consideration; its results justified inclusion of both items in the new system, with incentives from BC Hydro.

Several years of building and performance data helped inform the design of the new system. In addition to replacing the mechanical equipment, implementing the new system required replacing a fair amount of the piping and the primary pumps in the building, and the addition of new heating and chilled water buffer tanks.

  • Annual Savings:

  • $21,900 DOLLARS
  • 6.4 PAYBACK (YEARS)
  • 415 kw
  • 240,100 kWh
  • 9.6 GHG (TONNES C02e)

Project Outcomes

The new system began operating in the Spring of 2023 and functioned well in cooling mode from the start – in fact, according to building staff, that summer was the first time since the building opened that the system didn’t have to run 24/7 to maintain a comfortable temperature. Ongoing commissioning identified and resolved a number of issues over the next several months.

Challenges and Key Learnings

During equipment startup, it became apparent that there was a considerable gap, with regards to heating water temperatures produced by the ASHP, between the stated performance capability of the equipment and the “recommended” performance limits to avoid excessive wear and tear. To address this, a control strategy was developed that limited the amount of time the ASHP operated at higher temperature outputs while still allowing it to deliver as much of the load as possible. Where required, the supplementary electric boilers “topped up” the system temperature, ensuring that that it could be maintained even on the coldest days without overtaxing the ASHP.

 

 

Other issues identified:

  • The original design had anticipated less frictional loss in the pipes, leading to a greater-than-expected pressure drop on startup. However, the original design had also recognized the critical importance of ensuring adequate flow, so pumps had been oversized (and equipped with VSDs) out of an abundance of caution. This approach allowed the system to deliver the required flow despite the greater than anticipated friction without requiring changes to the equipment.
  • In the first few months of operation, lockouts on heating mode were found to be too aggressive, resulting in comfort complaints from occupants in some areas of the building. This was resolved by allowing the heat pump to operate over a greater range of conditions before switching over to the chiller. During colder weather, response time of the electric boiler was improved to allow the heating loop to reach target temperatures more quickly.
  • Troubleshooting cold zones identified numerous VAV boxes with faults. These faults, along with other issues with the overall building HVAC system, will be addressed in the future through the BC Hydro Continuous Optimization Program.

 

Testimonials

Lululemon

“SES consulting has been an exceptional consultant for our energy-efficiency studies. They bring deep mechanical engineering expertise, practical insight, and consistently deliver with high level of professionalism. We’ve been very happy with their work and would recommend them without hesitation.”

Rajaa Badaoui, Energy & Sustainability Program Manager
Lululemon

KingSett Capital

“There are very few engineering consulting firms we would trust to implement a full decarbonization strategy and deep energy retrofit, and SES is one of them.”

Kit Milnes, Vice President, Sustainability & Resilience
KingSett Capital

SD68 Nanaimo Ladysmith

“SES Consulting is an extraordinary firm to work with. They are very responsive to the client’s needs and coordinate with all parties throughout the process. I have had the pleasure working with SES on mechanical upgrades, decarbonization and optimization projects.

Their commitment to reducing the carbon footprint shines through in the organization and therefore, provides the best sustainable application for the client.
SES is an organization that delivers high quality engineering services with a staff that are always professional, organized, and helpful.”

Mary Zuccaro, Energy Manager
SD68 Nanaimo Ladysmith

Science World

“Science World hired SES to envision a Deep Energy Retrofit of our facility and support our funding application to the Federal Green and Inclusive Community Buildings (GICB) Program.
Scott Sinclair and his team acted as the Prime Consultant to pull together Architectural, Structural, Mechanical, Electrical, Solar PV, Building Envelope, Acoustic and Code Consulting professionals to virtually eliminate our GHG footprint as well as reducing our Net Energy by 45%.”

Hugh Swan, Director of Infrastructure and Facilities
Science World

Jawl

“We have worked with SES Consulting since 2007. SES has helped us with energy audits, continuous optimization studies, equipment selection, trouble shooting and consulting for design-build mechanical plant upgrades throughout our portfolio of office buildings.

Beyond their high level of technical expertise, the SES team have brought wisdom and a sense of partnership in helping us achieve our sustainability goals. They have been critical to us being on track to achieve our goal of reducing GHG emissions by 60% and our energy consumption by 50% by 2030.”

Karen Jawl, Director
Jawl Properties Ltd.

CEIT

“SES has proven through the years to be an excellent partner of CIET.

Their willingness to innovate on numerous projects of training development and delivery, in accordance with adult learning principles, demonstrates their commitment to contribute to a successful transition towards a low-carbon economy.

Their human-centric and problem-solving approach combined with their ability to always respect deadlines make them a partner of choice’’.

Alexandre Blanchette, Training Program Manager
CIET